← Back to Case Studies

Carer Visa Granted Despite Eight Australian Citizen Relatives in Sydney

Visa TypeCarer Visa
CategoryAll Cases

Case Summary

A carer visa application was refused on the basis that the caree had eight children who were all Australian citizens living in Sydney. We successfully argued before the Tribunal that, due to each child's personal and financial circumstances, none could reasonably provide the required care.

Background

Our client was physically unwell and needed a carer to assist her. She sponsored her son and his family to come to Australia on a Carer Visa. The initial application was refused because she had eight children who were all Australian citizens and lived in Sydney — the Department found that she should be able to obtain care from one of her existing Australian relatives.

Challenges

  • Eight Australian citizen children in Sydney meant the initial application was refused on the 'existing relatives' grounds
  • Demonstrating that despite their Australian residency, none of the eight children could reasonably provide care
  • Establishing that the applicant required personal family-based care she could not afford to obtain commercially

How We Helped

We appeared before the Tribunal and argued in detail why each of the eight children in Sydney was genuinely unable to provide the required care, due to individual time and financial constraints across the family. We also demonstrated that the caree could not afford professional live-in care and that the nature of her needs required someone close to her — specifically a family member rather than a commercial service.

Schedule a call to discover how our experience and expertise made it possible

Key Success Factors

  • Individual assessment of each of the eight children's circumstances establishing their genuine inability to provide care
  • Evidence that the caree's care needs required personal family involvement rather than a commercial service
  • Demonstration that the applicant could not afford live-in professional care
Schedule a call to discover how our experience and expertise made it possible

Outcome

The Tribunal accepted the argument. The applicant's son was granted a Carer Visa, and visas were also obtained for his wife and child.

Need Help With Your Visa Matter?

Every case is unique. Get personalized assessment of your situation from experienced migration professionals who understand complex immigration challenges.

Request Free Assessment